Worked example · 02
A self-review cannot become independent review
Can one person’s self-review satisfy a role that requires independent settlement?
Midday · provisional self-review
The observer supplies a self-review and an impact input, but the synthetic source requires an eligible independent reviewer who has not yet settled it.
This is a synthetic variation on the paper’s redacted public worked day. It teaches a branch of the model; it is not a private record, observed personal event or empirical finding.
World 03 / 03
Record Integrity Lab
Performance · provisional preview
Short answer
No. The preview may be visible, but the canonical route remains blocked.
01 · Moment
Observed time slice
A bounded event with context and provenance.
02 · Economic question
Economic value unavailable
No typed VC output is constituted here.
03 · Human question
+0.021 WellbeingScore movement
Wbefore 700.000 → Wafter 700.021
Show the calculation
Four questions, in order.
- 01
Start with the prior state
The event reads Wbefore = 700.000.
- 02
Ask the economic question
No typed Vcom is constituted for this case.
- 03
Ask the human-state question
The reviewed input produces deltaW = 0.021, so Wafter = 700.021.
- 04
Keep the units honest
No economic VC output is produced. A wellbeing movement is not converted into money or credits.
What this means
Role labels preserve who decided what. The fixture can calculate a preview without pretending the source is final.
What it does not mean
Provisional does not mean false; it means the required authority condition is incomplete.
Technical layerAudit the calculationInspect statuses, intermediate values, provenance, uncertainty and raw scenario structure.
- Source settlement
- provisional
- Impact review
- applied
- Replay eligibility
- blocked source provisional
- Valuation
- inputs ready source provisional
- Projection
- provisional preview only
- Wbefore
- 700.000
- Component delta
- 0.07
- deltaW
- 0.021
- Wafter
- 700.021
- Vcom_event
- null
- VCperformance_event
- null
Provisional preview calculation
Complete component-transition trace
Every input and intermediate value is carried by the stable synthetic fixture or derived from its pinned issuer-policy snapshot.
- Components before
- { "Physiology": 700, "Emotion": 700, "Feeling": 700, "Thought": 700, "Habit": 700, "Performance": 700 }
- calculated_Wbefore
- 700
- Affected component
- Performance
- component_before
- 700
- Band
- (600,700]
- band_rate
- 0.03
- adjustment_factor
- 0.005
- Direction
- positive
- Intensity
- medium
- intensity_multiplier
- 2/3
- maximum_move
- 0.105
- calculated_component_delta
- 0.07
- component_after
- 700.07
- component_weight
- 0.3
- calculated_deltaW
- 0.021
- calculated_Wafter
- 700.021
- Typed Vcom_event
- null
- Typed VCperformance_event
- null
maximum_move = 700 × 0.03 × 0.005 = 0.105
component_delta = 0.105 × 2/3 × 1 = 0.07
component_after = 700 + (0.07) = 700.07
deltaW = 0.07 × 0.3 = 0.021
Wafter = 700 + (0.021) = 700.021
Required case note
Impact justification
- Assumed synthetic evidence
- A synthetic founder self-review exists with an impact input, but the required independent GFE source review is absent.
- Reviewed decision input
- positive · medium (impact input only)
- Calculation demonstrated
- The calculator applies the pinned HouseOfBros Founder Policy v0.1 transition matrix to the declared component state. It does not infer direction or intensity from the evidence narrative.
- Decision rationale
- Source settlement remains provisional, so replay and canonical projection are blocked even though HouseOfBros impact review is separately represented.
- Alternative interpretations
- An independent reviewer may validate, correct, or reject the source claim.
- Uncertainty
- This synthetic case has not been calibrated against observed longitudinal evidence or independent reviewer agreement.
- Evidence-to-intensity rubric
- unvalidated. Direction and intensity are reviewed inputs; the calculator does not infer them from prose.
- Validation research required
- Independent-review agreement, delegation safeguards and appeals testing.